Week 11 Prompt: eBooks vs Physical Books

 I, like several others based on the posts I’ve read so far, used to be a bit of a book snob when it came to eBooks. I was dedicated to physical copies above all else, and if given the option, most of the time I still will opt for a physical copy of a book – but is one really better than the other? Physical books have the appeal of being tactile, something that you can feel, hold, and manually progress through by flipping pages. Many books, also, are formatted by their author with the intent of being in print, so some design elements or stylistic choices may not translate as well on an eReader –I’ve found this to be the case with poetry. When reading an eBook, a wonky looking line (meant to emphasize or stand out in print) might be all it takes to draw me out of a book and start thinking about the structure instead of the story.

With that said, eBooks have their own set of appeals, mainly relating to convenience and accessibility. Nearly everybody has a phone or portable computer today, so reading on a device takes up less space than handling a physical copy, and it eliminates concerns of travelling to a library to get/return books. With (most) e-readers as well, readers are no longer subject to constraints like proper lighting or book-safe locations (I couldn’t tell you why, but I am much more comfortable bringing my phone on a boat than a book). eBook options of upping font size, changing to more dyslexia-friendly fonts, etc. also offer opportunity for more patrons to enjoy the content – a large print physical copy of a less known book may be hard to come by, but an eBook can easily change to suit individual needs.

I don’t believe that reading in one format over the other makes you more of an expert of the genre, though I can see how that might be the case in the eyes of the public – I find myself thinking of it like music’s vinyl vs CD audio debate; there are pros and cons to each but in the end you’re still listening to the same album. That tactile element present in both of these (books and records) is very important to some people, so I can see why some people are still so against digital media! One study I pulled sought to examine any differences in reading comprehension between print books and eBooks. They found that “on most tests subjects performed identically” regardless of the reading medium, but that “on measures related to chronology and temporality, those who had read in the print pocket book, performed better than those who had read on a Kindle,” hypothesizing that the kinesthetic (tactile) feedback of reading and manipulating a printed book helps with these measures (Mangen et al., 2019, pg. 1). So there may be some merit in reading a physical copy over a digital one in some cases, but if the reading is being done for enjoyment this may not matter to the reader as much. Still, this is interesting to see! I imagine more research regarding any longterm affects of eBooks (and screen usage in general) will come forward as time passes as well, but for now my conclusion is "to each their own;" I'll be happy to see someone is reading at all, regardless of their medium of choice!

Reference:

Mangen, A., Olivier, G., & Velay, J.-L. (2019). Comparing comprehension of a long text read in print book and on Kindle: Where in the text and when in the story? Frontiers in Psychology, 10. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00038 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reading Profile

Like many, I was an avid reader as a child and into adolescence, with memorable favorites including the Percy Jackson , Septimus Heap , and Hunger Games series as well as The Goose Girl by Shannon Hale and The Hobbit . Once I reached high school, however, most of my time spent reading was for part of the curriculum, rather than books of my choosing, due in part to time constraints as well as medical restrictions. This continued through my undergraduate studies (where I thankfully took several literature electives), as well as my first year in this program, adjusting to an “adult” schedule. With that said, I thoroughly enjoyed several of my required readings over the years, featuring classics like A Tree Grows in Brooklyn , The Metamorphosis , and The Great Gatsby . My go-to favorite book outside of these is The Martian by Andy Weir, which I have revisited several times. Since my adult reading habits to this point have been fairly limited, I would not say that I am strictly dedicat
Read more

Special Topics Essay: Awards

For this assignment, I decided to explore literary awards, their merit, their impact, and whether readers do (or should) care about them. While I might not consider this to completely fall under the category of a literature review essay, much of the content does revolve around the published opinions of others in the literary world, the points that they make, and how those opinions connect with one another. One of the key points I touched on in this essay was the impact of awards on writers. While there is much contention around literary awards and who wins them, it is worth noting how impactful these awards can be for writers. Yes, an award can help an author's works be more popular, serving as an advertisement of sorts, but many awards also come with direct monetary prizes that can greatly impact writers' lives. Here's a brief excerpt: Generally, writing is not a very lucrative profession. According to the Authors Guild’s 2023 Author Income Survey, “median author income fo
Read more

Week 5 Prompt Response

  RE: eBook-only books and reviewing The popularity of eBook-only books shows that professional reviews may not be necessary for a book to be successful, but I imagine this would affect collection development if the library staff were looking for these criteria. As trends shift, it may be necessary for library staff to turn to other sources for collection development if professional reviewers are not changing the types of books they review. RE: Amazon vs Blog Review I am not confident using these two reviews to make a collection development decision. Both reviews read as stream-of-consciousness writing, lacking focus on the book (or at least the aspects that would aid my decision-making). It is difficult to tell how the book might appeal to a wider audience since the opinions (about the book and Christmas itself, from the looks of things) are so individualized/personal. RE: Angela’s Ashes Having read these professional reviews, I would feel encouraged to add Angela’s Ashes to
Read more